Creamy Mushroom Risotto with Truffle Oil

The first time I made mushroom risotto, I accidentally spilled a drop of truffle oil on my wrist and spent the entire evening catching whiffs of that intoxicating aroma. There's something meditative about the constant stirring, watching the rice transform from hard kernels into this luxurious, creamy canvas for the earthy mushrooms. My kitchen windows fogged up as the stock simmered away, creating this cozy little world that smelled like an Italian grandmother's home.

Last autumn, I served this at a small dinner party when the rain was tapping against the windows. My friend Marco, who normally boasts about his Italian mothers cooking, fell silent after his first bite before whispering, This might be better than Mamas, just dont tell her I said that. We all laughed, glasses clinked, and somehow the risotto disappeared faster than the wine that night, which never happens in my circle of friends.

Ingredients

• 400g mixed mushrooms: I like using cremini for their meaty base flavor, shiitake for their woodsy intensity, and some button mushrooms for their mild sweetness, creating a more complex mushroom symphony.
• 300g Arborio rice: Please dont substitute regular rice here, Arborio has that magical starch content that creates the signature creamy texture without becoming mushy.
• 1 medium onion, finely chopped: The finer you chop, the more it melts into the background of the risotto while infusing everything with its sweet foundation.
• 2 garlic cloves, minced: Fresh garlic makes a world of difference, those pre minced jars just dont release the same aromatic oils that perfume the entire dish.
• 1L vegetable stock: Keep this simmering hot in a separate pot, adding cold stock will shock the rice and interrupt that creamy development youre working toward.
• 120ml dry white wine: I discovered that a crisp Pinot Grigio works beautifully here, and conveniently leaves enough in the bottle for the cook to enjoy while stirring.
• 60g unsalted butter, divided: Adding half at the beginning creates a foundation of richness, while the remaining half stirred in at the end creates that signature glossy finish that makes restaurant risotto so special.
• 60g freshly grated Parmesan: Please grate it yourself right before using, the pre grated stuff contains anti caking agents that affect how beautifully it melts into your creation.
• Truffle oil: Just 2 3 teaspoons transform this from delicious to transcendent, but add it at the very end, as heat diminishes its aromatic magic.

Instructions

Prepare your mise en place:

Chop everything beforehand and position your ingredients within arms reach, because once you start stirring that risotto, youll be somewhat tethered to the pot. Having your hot stock in a separate pot with a ladle ready makes the process flow like a gentle stream.

Create your flavor foundation:

As the olive oil and butter melt together, their aromas will begin to dance in your kitchen. When you add those onions, listen for that gentle sizzle that tells you the heat is just right, and youll know theyre done when they turn translucent but not brown, soft and sweet rather than caramelized.

Develop the mushroom magic:

After adding the garlic, stir constantly for that minute to prevent any bitter burning. When the mushrooms join the party, they might seem like too much at first, but watch how they transform and shrink as they release their moisture and concentrate their flavor.

Toast the rice:

This step might seem minor but its crucial for developing flavor. Youll know the rice is properly toasted when it makes a subtle clicking sound against your pan and the edges become translucent while the centers remain pearly white.

Begin the meditation:

As you add the wine, inhale deeply to catch that initial burst of aroma before it cooks away. The wine should bubble vigorously at first, and youll stir until the sharp alcohol smell dissipates into a sweeter fragrance.

The heart of risotto making:

This is where patience becomes your greatest virtue. Add stock one ladleful at a time, stirring in wide, gentle motions, and wait until most liquid is absorbed before adding more. The rice will gradually release its starches, creating that signature creamy texture that makes risotto so special.

Test for doneness:

After about 18 minutes, start tasting the rice. Perfect risotto should be al dente, with a slight firmness at the center of each grain. The overall texture should be creamy and flowing, not stiff or soupy, what Italians call all onda, or wavy.

The finishing glory:

Once off heat, the final additions of butter and Parmesan work their transformative magic. Stir with purpose here, watching as everything melds into glossy perfection. Season carefully, as Parmesan brings its own saltiness to the party.

The truffle finale:

Drizzling truffle oil should be done with reverence, as if performing the final brushstroke on a masterpiece. Do this at the table if possible, letting your guests experience that intoxicating aroma as it blooms before their eyes.

Save to Pinterest

One evening when everything in life felt particularly heavy, I decided making this risotto would be my form of therapy. Standing there stirring, inhaling the earthy mushroom scent mixed with butter and wine, I felt my shoulders drop and my mind quiet for the first time that week. By the time I drizzled that truffle oil and took my first bite, sitting alone at my kitchen counter, I realized good food isnt just about feeding others, sometimes its the act of creating something beautiful just for yourself that matters most.

The Rice Whisperer's Secrets

After years of making risotto, I've developed what my friends call my rice whispering technique. I now use my wooden spoon more like a folding tool than a stirrer, gently encouraging the rice rather than aggressively moving it. The gentler approach prevents breaking the rice grains while still developing that starchy creaminess we're after. When I'm in the zone, there's a rhythm to it, almost like the rice and I are dancing together in a quiet kitchen waltz.

Making Friends with Mushrooms

I once made the rookie mistake of washing mushrooms under running water, which left them waterlogged and pale in flavor. Now I treat them with proper respect, only brushing away any dirt with a soft cloth or paper towel. For deeper flavor, I sometimes let the sliced mushrooms sit on the counter for 15 minutes before cooking, which concentrates their earthy essence through a bit of air-drying. The difference in taste is subtle but noticeable, especially in a dish where mushrooms are the star.

Serving Suggestions and Pairings

The first time I served this risotto at a dinner party, I overthought the accompaniments and created three elaborate side dishes that nobody touched because the risotto was completely satisfying on its own. Now I know that simplicity is key, perhaps just a crisp green salad dressed with lemon and good olive oil to cut through the richness.

• If you want to elevate this for a special occasion, try serving smaller portions in elegant bowls as a first course before a simple protein main.
• For wine pairing, a mineral forward white like Gavi di Gavi or an unoaked Chardonnay complements without overwhelming the truffle notes.
• Leftovers transform beautifully into arancini the next day, just roll cold risotto into balls, stuff with a bit of mozzarella, bread, and fry until golden.

Save to Pinterest

This risotto has become my culinary love language, the dish I make when words arent enough to express care. Whether comforting a friend through heartbreak or celebrating life's small victories, these creamy, truffle scented bowls somehow always say exactly what needs to be said.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ Why do you need to stir risotto constantly?

Continuous stirring releases the starch from Arborio rice grains, creating the signature creamy texture. This process, called the "mantecatura," is essential for achieving authentic risotto consistency without adding cream.

→ Can you make this ahead of time?

Risotto is best served immediately after cooking. However, you can prep ingredients in advance and reheat gently with additional warm stock if needed, though texture may be slightly less creamy than freshly made.

→ What mushrooms work best for this dish?

A combination of cremini, shiitake, and button mushrooms provides depth and variety. For even richer flavor, add rehydrated porcini mushrooms, which intensify the earthy notes that complement truffle oil beautifully.

→ Is there a vegan version?

Yes. Substitute vegan butter for regular butter and use nutritional yeast or a vegan Parmesan alternative instead of cheese. The risotto technique remains unchanged, and truffle oil is naturally vegan.

→ What wine should you use for cooking?

A dry white wine like Pinot Grigio or Sauvignon Blanc works well. Avoid overly oaky or sweet wines, as the acidity helps cut through the richness while the wine's flavor integrates subtly into the rice.

→ How do you know when risotto is done?

The rice should be creamy and tender with a slight firmness (al dente) when bitten. The mixture should flow slightly on the plate but hold its shape. This typically takes 18-20 minutes of gradual stock addition.