Creamy Chicken Mushroom Pie

I was standing in my kitchen on a rainy Tuesday, staring at leftover chicken and a sad bag of mushrooms, when I decided to stop overthinking dinner. What came out of the oven an hour later was this golden-topped pie that made my neighbor knock on the door to ask what smelled so good. Sometimes the best recipes are born from whatever's in the fridge and a little bit of hunger-fueled courage.

The first time I made this for friends, I underestimated how much they'd eat. I watched three grown adults scrape the dish clean and debate who got the last crispy corner of pastry. That's when I learned to always make extra, because this pie disappears faster than you'd think.

Ingredients

• Chicken thighs or breasts: I prefer thighs because they stay tender and juicy even if you slightly overcook them, but breasts work beautifully if that's what you have on hand.
• Mushrooms: White or cremini both work, slice them thick so they hold their shape and give you that earthy, meaty bite in every spoonful.
• Onion and garlic: These build the aromatic base, and I've learned that chopping the onion finely means it melts into the sauce instead of chunking up.
• Carrot: A small dice adds a hint of sweetness and a pop of color that makes the filling feel complete.
• Butter and olive oil: Using both gives you rich flavor and a higher smoke point, perfect for browning without burning.
• Flour: This thickens the sauce just enough to coat the back of a spoon, creating that silky texture we're after.
• Chicken stock: Use good quality stock if you can, it's the backbone of the whole filling and you'll taste the difference.
• Heavy cream: This is what makes the sauce luxurious and comforting, don't skip it or substitute with milk.
• Dijon mustard: Just a teaspoon adds a subtle tang that balances the richness without shouting mustard.
• Puff pastry: Store-bought is a gift, let it thaw in the fridge overnight so it rolls out without cracking.
• Egg wash: Brushing this on the pastry turns it into a glossy, golden crown that makes the whole pie look bakery-perfect.
• Fresh parsley: Stirred in at the end, it brightens everything and adds a whisper of freshness to the creamy filling.

Instructions

Preheat and Prep:

Get your oven to 200°C so it's ready when you are. This also gives you time to gather everything without rushing.

Brown the Chicken:

Heat oil and butter until shimmering, then add your chicken in a single layer and let it sizzle undisturbed for a minute before stirring. You want golden edges, not steamed meat, so don't crowd the pan.

Build the Filling Base:

In the same pan, cook your onion, carrot, and garlic until they smell sweet and the edges soften. Then add the mushrooms and let them release their moisture, cooking until they start to brown and concentrate their flavor.

Make the Sauce:

Sprinkle in the flour and stir it around for a full minute to cook out the raw taste. Slowly pour in the stock while stirring constantly so no lumps form, then nestle the chicken back in.

Finish the Filling:

Stir in the cream and mustard, letting everything simmer gently until the sauce thickens and clings to the chicken. Add the parsley, taste it, and adjust the salt and pepper until it makes you want to grab a spoon.

Assemble the Pie:

Pour the filling into your pie dish and let it cool for 10 minutes, this stops the pastry from getting soggy. Drape the puff pastry over the top, press the edges to seal, trim the excess, and cut a small vent in the center so steam can escape.

Glaze and Bake:

Brush the pastry with beaten egg, making sure you cover every inch for that deep golden color. Bake until the top is puffed and crisp, then let it rest for 5 minutes so the filling settles and you don't burn your tongue.

Save to Pinterest

I remember serving this to my mom on a cold evening, and halfway through her slice she looked up and said it reminded her of Sunday dinners from her childhood. That's when I realized this pie wasn't just dinner, it was comfort wrapped in pastry, a little piece of home on a plate.

Storing and Reheating

Leftovers keep in the fridge for up to three days, covered tightly. Reheat individual portions in a hot oven to bring back the pastry's crispness, microwaving works in a pinch but the crust won't be the same. You can also freeze the assembled unbaked pie, just add an extra 10 minutes to the baking time when you cook it from frozen.

Serving Suggestions

I love this pie with a simple side of steamed green beans or a handful of dressed greens to cut through the richness. Mashed potatoes feel like overkill, but a light salad with a sharp vinaigrette is the perfect partner. On colder nights, I've even served it with roasted root vegetables and it felt like a proper feast.

Variations and Swaps

If you have leftover rotisserie chicken, shred it and skip the browning step entirely, just fold it in with the sauce. Turkey works beautifully here too, especially after the holidays when you need a new way to use up the meat. A splash of white wine added with the stock gives the filling a little more depth, and swapping half the mushrooms for leeks adds a gentle sweetness that I absolutely love.

• Try adding a handful of frozen peas in the last few minutes of simmering for a pop of color and sweetness.
• Use a mix of wild mushrooms if you want a more earthy, complex flavor.
• Top with mashed potato instead of pastry for a cottage pie twist that's just as satisfying.

Save to Pinterest

This pie has become my go-to when I want to feel like I've really cooked something special without spending all day in the kitchen. I hope it fills your home with the same warmth and makes someone you love ask for seconds.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ What type of chicken is best for this dish?

Boneless, skinless thighs or breasts work well; thighs offer more juiciness while breasts provide leaner meat.

→ Can I substitute the mushrooms with another vegetable?

Yes, cremini or white mushrooms are ideal, but you could try diced zucchini or cooked leeks for a different flavor.

→ How do I ensure the sauce is creamy and thick?

Cooking the flour briefly and gradually adding stock before cream helps avoid lumps and achieves a rich consistency.

→ What is the best way to get a flaky pastry crust?

Use ready-rolled puff pastry chilled and handle it minimally before baking to maintain flakiness and prevent shrinking.

→ Can I prepare the filling in advance?

Yes, you can prepare and cool the filling beforehand; reheat gently before covering with pastry and baking.